Stephen Diehl Profile picture
4 May, 19 tweets, 4 min read
Let's talk about surrogate money scams and how they are used to cover up the liquidity crisis at heart of the global crypto fraud. (1/) 🧵
Contrary to myth, it's actually entirely legal for private companies to issue private money, but with some caveats.

Whenever you buy a Starbucks gift card or top up the mobile app you're effectively trading your dollars or pounds for Starbucks-bucks. (2/)
Starbucks has around $1.6 billion in stored value card liabilities outstanding. This is a great line of business for them because these dollars are locked into being spent at their coffee shops and the company gets a giant pile of actual money they can spend anywhere. (3/)
It's actually even better, Starbucks doesn’t pay any interest on the balances held in the Starbucks app or gift cards. And when you buy these products, you are providing the company with effectively an interest-free loan. (4/)
However they take that money and deposit and invest the actual money and make a return on that float which just has to exceed their liabilities. It's a good racket and the only legal requirement is that they provide the cash-equivalence of coffee when you use your gift card. (5/)
However there's a key point that makes this legal, you can't walk into a Starbucks and redeem your gift card for cash. Gift cards are not a cash-equivalent assets since money can only flow in one direction. (6/)
It turns out that if you did let people do that, most of the people buying your gift cards would be in organized crime and would use your service to take dirty money tied to crime and turn it into clean funds, through your company, and that's not legal or good for business. (7/)
Now if you're a greedy crypto bro with loose morals, you don't see this as a problem but as an opportunity.

And so they decided to build surrogate dollars for entities that are so insanely dodgy no bank will touch them. And then they cut themselves in on that fraud. (9/)
These so-called stablecoin projects are effectively the crypto equivalent Starbucks gift cards, except their accountants are constantly cooking their books and they're not redeemable for anything. (10/)
When you run an untouchable business that can't legally operate anywhere in US and Europe, turns out most banks don't want you as their customer.

Because having their name on the front page of Wall Street Journal for ties to organised crime isn't so great for business. (11/)
If you're shut out of international banking AND you run a offshore money-transmitter service you have a huge liquidity problem.

You're constantly struggling to find dollars and set up new shell companies and new accounts before the old ones get frozen or investigated. (12/)
Cryptocurrency exchanges are constantly playing a game of cat and mouse with the FBI, FinCEN, and the long arm of the Justice Department. Because the only real purpose of using crypto is doing things that are otherwise illegal. (13/)

When customers wire money to exchanges in the Cayman Islands, the operators immediately run off with the cash. In order to keep the illusion of liquidity they issue these IOU stablecoin dollars and pretend they're redeemable because there's no actual real dollars anywhere. (14/)
If we take any one of these allegedly multibillion-cap cryptcon schemes, what we actually have is a bunch of of people who *think* they have a claim on some of those billions of dollars when the amount of real dollars is far far less.

Likely in the tens of millions. (15/)
To paper over this liquidity crunch, people keep issuing billions of unbacked stablecoins which do nothing but obscure and transfer the risk from one asset to another.

When exchanges trade Dollar stablecoins it's because there's no real money anywhere for withdrawals. (16/)
If even a tiny fraction of people decided to redeem their magic beans it would quicky turn into Lord of the Flies with customers fighting over 1-2% dollar reserves of the alleged value of the token.

And there's no deposit insurance or reserve requirements on any of this. (17/)
The entire crypto space is a house of cards just waiting to collapse on this inevitable liquidity crisis.

Naive investors buying into the crypto scam need to understand a simple fact:

1) Paper wealth is not real wealth.
2) Notional value does not factor in risk.

(18/)
There is insane counterparty risk associated with the notional value of these unregulated crypto assets, and if you're trusting a shell company in the Cayman Islands to make due on its debts then you're a fool.

/fin

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Stephen Diehl

Stephen Diehl Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @smdiehl

5 May
This year #ESG investing has a lot of momentum in Europe, and many funds are interested in how crypto factors into their portfolios. (1/) 🧵
For those that don't know, ESG stands for:

* Environmental
* Social
* Corporate Governance

It's an investment philosophy that tries to allocate capital towards companies that are better than their peers with regards to sustainability and societal impact. (2/)
Investing in directly cryptocurrency is one of the most anti-ESG investment you can possibly make.

The environmental exposure of crypto is a nightmare that directly contributes to carbon emissions and climate change at the level of nation states. (3/)

ofnumbers.com/2021/02/14/bit…
Read 22 tweets
3 May
The mental gymnastics Facebookers do is incredible and now they have the audacity to say "there's good people here now".

No, literally every day that company tries to create the most optimally evil lines of business in the entire sector. And they're unapologetic about it.
Addicting children under 13 to Instagram.

theguardian.com/technology/202…
Regulatory arbitrage to build a surveillance system on top of their own currency.

foreignpolicy.com/2019/06/24/971…
Read 5 tweets
2 May
Let's talk about the moral hazard of crypto and how it incentivizes fraud in tech companies. (1/) 🧵
Term "moral hazard" is financial jargon for an entity that has an incentive to take on greater risk because they don't personally bear the consequences of their actions. (2/)
If you invest other people's money there's a well-known perverse incentive to take on riskier positions because the incentive of your pay is performance-based and tied to outsized returns. And you personally see none of the downside if the positions fail. (3/)
Read 23 tweets
22 Apr
I keep using game theory and quantitative finance terms to describe why #bitcoin is a terrible investment. But let me try a different metaphor that might be more relatable. 🧵

Poker. 🃏

(1/)
In a poker game people show up with cash, a buy-in. They convert this money with the house to get tokens which they then use to play. (2/)
If you sum over all players buy-in you get the total possible winnings any one player could possibly win. This is a fixed value that can't increase unless more players are added. (3/)
Read 13 tweets
20 Apr
Let's talk about why the #bitcoin narrative is intellectually incoherent and why the emperor has no clothes. 🧵 (1/)
Bitcoiners are deeply confused people. In particular they are duplicitous (or genuinely confused) about the purpose of their allegedly paradigm-shifting technology and whether it is:

A) An Investment
B) A Currency

(2/)
These two classes of financial instruments are complete opposites. The better something is as a speculative investment, the worse it is as an actual currency.

However crypto advocates want to use and refer to the properties of both simultaneously without justifying either.

(3/)
Read 19 tweets
19 Apr
When economists describe crypto assets like bitcoin as a "greater fool" investment what do they mean? 🧵 (1/)
It's important to note the actual buying behaviour people have with crypto assets.

People buy them from a service like Robinhood or Coinbase and hold their tokens in hopes that "number go up" so it can be redeemed for dollars. This is effectively 99% of consumer behavior. (2/)
Because there's no utility or cashflow from a bitcoin, they only way one can possibly make money from this scheme is for the exchange who holds your tokens to find someone who will buy your tokens from you for more than you paid. (3/)
Read 15 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!